Get verified for the Top 100 →Get in the running for the top 100 property managers in the nation. Get verified today to be in the running →

Top Property Managers in Indiana

Browse verified property management companies across 749 Indiana cities — compare TrueMatch™ scores, coverage areas, and owner-verified reviews

749

Cities

13

Property Managers

992

ZIP Codes

13

Ranked

Midtowne Realty

Fort Wayne, IN + 19 more

4.0· 94 reviews223 doors33 years

PMI Indianapolis

Indianapolis, IN + 41 more

4.5· 662 reviews836 doors9 yearsSingle-FamilyCondominiumsTownhousesDuplexes / Triplexes / FourplexesMulti-FamilyStudent HousingAffordable / Subsidized HousingHomeowners Associations (HOAs)Condominium Associations (COAs)Commercial PropertiesMixed-UseLicensedInsured

Hoosier Homes

Indianapolis, IN

3.8· 32 reviewsExcellent800 doors8 yearsSingle-FamilyAffordable / Subsidized HousingCondominiumsDuplexes / Triplexes / FourplexesMulti-FamilyTownhouses

WILMOTH Group

Anderson, IN + 22 more

4.3· 850 reviewsExcellent968 doors31 yearsSingle-FamilyAffordable / Subsidized HousingCondominiumsDuplexes / Triplexes / FourplexesMulti-FamilyTownhousesLicensedInsured

CRM Properties

Indianapolis, IN, Kokomo, IN

4.5· 852 reviews825 doors14 yearsSingle-FamilyAffordable / Subsidized HousingCondominiumsDuplexes / Triplexes / FourplexesMulti-FamilyTownhousesLicensedInsured

Not sure which Indiana manager fits your property?

Get your TrueMatch™

ES Property Management

Bargersville, IN + 9 more

4.3· 273 reviews316 doors15 yearsSingle-FamilyCondominiumsTownhousesDuplexes / Triplexes / FourplexesLicensedInsured

Indiana Property Management Group LLC

Avon, IN + 12 more

4.6· 135 reviews360 doors11 yearsSingle-FamilyCondominiumsDuplexes / Triplexes / FourplexesTownhousesLicensedInsured

Mackie Properties

Bedford, IN + 15 more

4.1· 88 reviews354 doors18 yearsSingle-FamilyCondominiumsTownhousesDuplexes / Triplexes / FourplexesMulti-FamilyStudent HousingHomeowners Associations (HOAs)Condominium Associations (COAs)Commercial PropertiesLicensedInsured

PMI Midwest

Avon, IN + 16 more

4.4· 849 reviews1,075 doors16 yearsSingle-FamilyAffordable / Subsidized HousingCommercial PropertiesCondominiumsDuplexes / Triplexes / FourplexesMixed-UseMulti-FamilyStudent HousingTownhousesLicensedInsured

PMI NWI

Valparaiso, IN + 14 more

4.7· 998 reviews

Red Door Property Management

Avon, IN + 13 more

4.5· 474 reviews500 doors14 yearsSingle-FamilyCondominiumsDuplexes / Triplexes / FourplexesMulti-FamilyTownhousesVacation Rentals / Short-Term RentalsLicensedInsured

T&H Realty Services, Inc.

Anderson, IN, Indianapolis, IN, Kokomo, IN

4.5· 1277 reviews1,250 doors17 yearsSingle-FamilyTownhousesCondominiumsDuplexes / Triplexes / FourplexesMulti-FamilyLicensedInsured

True Care Properties

Elkhart, IN + 6 more

5.0· 4 reviews52 doors2 yearsSingle-FamilyDuplexes / Triplexes / FourplexesLicensedInsured

Find your perfect Indiana property manager

No credit card required
Instant results
No property manager can pay to change their score

About Property Management in Indiana

Verified data from PropertyManagement.com's TrueMatch™ network

Indiana offers stable rental markets with investor-friendly regulations. Find property managers experienced in Indianapolis, Fort Wayne, and college towns who focus on consistent cash flow generation.

Our platform helps you connect with verified property management companies across Indiana, with special focus on their performance, reliability, and local expertise.

Cities in Indiana

Browse verified property managers across 60 Indiana cities.

Property management in Indiana

Indiana (IN) has 749 cities with property management coverage and 13 verified property management companies across 992 ZIP codes.

Property owners in Indiana use TrueMatch™ on PropertyManagement.com to compare managers by real performance data — verified owner feedback, service quality, cost efficiency, and maintenance responsiveness — rather than paid reviews.

Each city page includes verified manager counts, ZIP coverage areas, median rent data, and TrueMatch™ performance tier distributions to help owners make informed hiring decisions for their specific location.

Looking for property managers in a different location?

Enter your property address to get started with personalized property manager recommendations.