Indiana Property Management Group LLC

Indianapolis, IN,Fishers, IN,Carmel, IN,Greenwood, IN
TrueMatch Score81.44%
Quick summary
Indiana Property Management Group LLC is a property management company based in Indianapolis, IN, with a TrueMatch™ score of 81.44 out of 100, They serve 13 surrounding markets, They manage 360+ units and and have been in business since (11 years).
300+
Doors Managed
11
Years Experience
100+
Google Reviews

Company Overview

Indiana Property Management Group is the trusted source for property management and real estate investing in Central Indiana. Our team is experienced and large enough to serve all your needs — yet not so large that you will feel overlooked. Our focus is on providing transparent fees, consistent communication, and maximizing the profit from your real estate investments. We care about your success and treat each property as if it were our own. As a local company, we are proud to provide tenants with quality housing and great customer service — helping you reduce turnover costs and enjoy stronger long-term performance.

Customer Reviews & Ratings

Google
4.5
Based on 125 reviews
Better Business Bureau
A+

BBB and Yelp ratings are influenced by ads or paid accreditation. They are still shown for transparency but don’t affect TrueMatch score.

Service Areas

Market coverage:

Indianapolis, IN ,Fishers, IN ,Carmel, IN ,Greenwood, IN ,Noblesville, IN ,Plainfield, IN ,Westfield, IN ,Brownsburg, IN ,Avon, IN ,Whitestown, IN

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes Indiana Property Management Group different from other companies?

Indiana Property Management Group combines personalized service with professional expertise. We are local to Central Indiana and small enough to provide hands-on support — yet experienced enough to manage any situation that comes with rental property ownership. We prioritize your profitability through transparent fees, proactive communication, and maintenance decisions that protect your investment for the long term.

Do you mark up maintenance costs by a percentage? Wouldn’t that create a conflict of interest?

No percentage markups — ever. Unlike some companies, we do not profit when you spend more on repairs. Instead, we charge a flat, low-cost coordination fee for each maintenance request. That means whether an appliance needs a small fix or full replacement, our incentive is the same: helping you make the most cost-effective decision for your property.

I’ve never been a landlord before. Can this be as “passive” as possible?

Yes. We specialize in supporting seasoned investors and homeowners who decide to rent instead of sell. Our team guides you step-by-step through leasing, legal compliance, repairs, rent collection, and tenant relations — handling the heavy lifting so you can enjoy a passive investment experience. We keep you updated before key decisions arise, ensuring full transparency without the stress.

Do you offer discounts for multiple rental properties?

Yes! We offer tiered pricing for owners with more than one rental unit in Central Indiana. Whether you own two properties or a growing investment portfolio, we can structure pricing to help boost your returns.

How do you screen tenants to ensure they are reliable and responsible?

We use a rigorous, data-driven screening process that evaluates income, employment, rental history, credit reports, criminal background, and more. Our approach leads to a below-average eviction rate and stronger long-term tenancy — helping protect your property and rental income.

Are there any surprise or hidden fees?

Absolutely not. We believe in upfront, transparent pricing. Every cost is explained during your first call with us — no surprises later. When you win, we win.

How much rent can I charge for my property?

Rental pricing depends on the property’s location, condition, amenities, age, and current demand in the local market. Setting the right price is critical — too high and the home sits vacant, too low and you leave profit on the table. Indiana Property Management Group conducts a detailed market analysis using comparable rentals, vacancy data, school district insights, and seasonal trends in Central Indiana. We’ll recommend a rent amount designed to maximize your occupancy and long-term returns.

How is the TrueMatch™ Score calculated?

We evaluate property management services across four key areas: performance efficiency, cost-effectiveness, reliability, and credibility. These scores reflect how well we manage vacancies and rent collection, deliver value for money, maintain consistent service and communication, and uphold industry standards through experience and proven success.
Indiana Property Management Group LLC (TrueMatch Score: 82%) - Reliable Property Manager on PropertyManagement.com

Company Details

4929 E 96th St, Indianapolis, IN 46240

Property Types

Condominiums Duplexes / Triplexes / Fourplexes Single-Family Townhouses

Credentials

Licensed Insured

Asset Class Focus

A-Class B-Class

Company Size

Mid-Market [200-499]

Years in Business

11 years

Founded Year

2014

Verification Status

Verified by PropertyManagement.com

Contact Information

Ready to Get Started?

Connect with this verified property manager today.