New: Industry Report →
Quick summary

WILMOTH Group is a property management company based in Indianapolis, IN. They serve 23 surrounding markets. They are ranked #74 nationally. They manage 968+ units. They have 31+ years of experience.

Verified by 2 owners

See Ratings
900+
Doors Managed
31
Years Experience
851
Google Reviews

Company Overview

WILMOTH Group has been serving Central Indiana residential investors for over 30 years. Our focus is on providing innovative solutions for residential real estate. As a family-oriented team, we operate with a focus on integrity and strive to add value to your investing experience.

Service area map

Area: smoothed merge of ~5 mi buffers (≈2 mi gap close). Dots: each ZIP centroid (darker = primary). Illustrative only. © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap

Customer Reviews & Ratings

Google

4.3

Based on 851 reviews

Better Business Bureau

A+

Based on 37 reviews

BBB and Yelp ratings are influenced by ads or paid accreditation. They are still shown for transparency but don't affect TrueMatch™ score.

Homeowner Survey Results

Data last updated on 02/09/2026, 11:59 AM CST

Overall Satisfaction?
10/10
Leasing Performance?
10/10
Maintenance Communication?
10/10
Maintenance Cost Value?
8.8/10
Accounting & Financial Reporting?
8.8/10
Vacancy Time?
10/10

Company reviews

A**** S.
Wilmouth is a great property management group. They helped to stabilize and fully lease our 35 unit multi-family.
D**** S.
We work exclusively with Max as our primary point of communication, and we couldn’t be happier with the level of service he provides. He meets with us monthly and consistently gives clear, detailed updates on the property’s performance. Under the Wilmoth Group, the building has been filled with reliable tenants, and overall performance has been strong. We now have a solid mix of tenants who pay on time, and the property is being managed very effectively and efficiently.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long has WILMOTH Group been in business?

WILMOTH Group, established in 1994 as Results Plus, Inc., has been serving real estate investors for over three decades. Celebrating the 31st anniversary in 2024, the company continues to deliver expert real estate solutions.

Will I be assigned one point of contact?

Yes. Each Rental Owner is assigned a Portfolio Manager (PM) who meets regularly to answer questions and provide updates, with support from other team members as needed.

How does WILMOTH Group provide efficient operations for my properties?

The team follows defined departments, processes, workflows, and daily tasks to ensure ongoing success of your properties.

How do I find my WILMOTH Group property management docs?

Log in to the Owner Portal and open the Rental Owner tab to download agreements, leases, manuals, and addendums.

Is WILMOTH Group an electronic payment and receipts manager?

Tenants pay rent online, accelerating cash flow by about three days. Funds are settled and sent to owners electronically by the 14th each month, with transfer notifications; bank posting can take up to three days.

Does WILMOTH Group have a monthly distribution schedule?

Yes. As monthly rent payments are received, funds are processed and delivered electronically to the designated bank account each month.

How are rental applicants screened?

Applicants are underwritten with checks for credit, eviction and residence history, employment and income, and criminal records against criteria, including landlord references, to reduce evictions (target ~3%).