Get verified for the Top 100 →
Midtowne Realty logo

Midtowne Realty

VerifiedElite · TrueMatch™ Verified
400+Doors managed
33Years in business
10Property owners surveyed
4.0Google · 88 reviews

We’re Midtowne Realty, a family-owned and operated business in downtown Fort Wayne. Our Mission is to help owners, tenants, and our community thrive by managing property well. We were founded 30 years ago by our owner and president, Eric Fisher. Eric is passionate about the spaces that people live in, and the effect our homes have on our quality of life. As a team, we embrace this vision. We help provide urban living options, proudly contributing to the quality of downtown Fort Wayne and the surrounding neighborhoods. Mitch, Eric’s son, has been part of our team for 15 years, and in that time has worked in every department of the business. In January 2019, Mitch became a co-owner and now runs the day-to-day operations. As a team, we work hard to manage our buildings and serve our residents in a way that promotes a positive environment. We have noticed that when residents feel we care about them, they start caring about us and our properties. They stay longer, and give us good referrals. This begins an upward spiral of respect and positivity that benefits us all: owners, residents, managers, maintenance personnel, and the surrounding community. It is our objective to be a positive experience in your life and work towards solutions when issues arise. Our relationship with our customers and owners is our priority over growth. We seek to maintain a thriving business, by providing a quality product and excellent service to our clients and customers. Thank you for considering our company; we appreciate your business!

Verified Performance

Measured from the company’s own management software, connected read-only to PropertyManagement.com, or from reports it uploads and we check.

Speedy Leasing

Verified

Speedy Repair

3 days

Median days to complete repairs

Verified

Occupancy Rate

94.1%

Occupancy rate

Verified

Rent Collection Rate

98.87%

Rent collection rate

Verified

Verified Credentials

Credentials are checked before they appear here: memberships against the association’s roster, training against the issuer, and accounting and pricing practices against independent data.

Rental Price Accuracy

Client survey results

Property owner survey results

Based on 10 property owner survey responses, collected by PropertyManagement.com directly from Midtowne’s clients.

Overall Satisfaction

10 property owner responses

Very dissatisfiedVery satisfied
9.5/10

Leasing Performance

9.5/10
Very dissatisfiedVery satisfied

Call Response

10.0/10
Very dissatisfiedVery satisfied

Accounting & Financial Reporting

8.8/10
Very confusingVery easy to understand

Maintenance Communication

9.4/10
7+ daysUnder 24 hours

Vacancy Time

7.8/10
61+ days0-14 days
Verified client survey aggregateData last updated Sep 19, 2026

Service area map

Area: smoothed merge of ~5 mi buffers (≈2 mi gap close). Dots: each ZIP centroid (darker = primary). Illustrative only. © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap

Customer Reviews & Ratings

Google
4.0

Based on 88 reviews

Better Business Bureau
NR

BBB and Yelp ratings are influenced by ads or paid accreditation. They are shown for transparency but don’t affect a TrueMatch™ score.

Frequently Asked Questions

What types of properties does Midtowne Realty manage?

Midtowne Realty specializes in managing single-family homes, duplexes / triplexes / fourplexes, multi-family apartments, vacation rentals / short-term rentals, commercial properties, mixed-use properties in the Fort Wayne, IN, New Haven, IN, Huntertown, IN area.

What services are included in their property management?

Services include: property management, tenant screening, maintenance coordination, financial reporting, lease management.