Get verified for the Top 100 →
Sales and Marketing Guide

How to Use Your TrueMatch™ Profile To Close More Deals

Where your verified profile fits at every step of the property owner sales process, with copy you can paste

Last updated
10 minRead time
How to Use Your TrueMatch™ Profile To Close More Deals

Every property manager tells property owners they pick up the phone and keep repair bills fair. Property owners have heard it before, usually from the manager who let them down.

Your TrueMatch™ profile, the verified profile property owners see on PropertyManagement.com, lets you stop saying it. It shows what your own property owners told us in surveys we collect directly from your clients, plus the operating numbers we verified from your software or your reports. The property owner gets proof from a third party, and you get to skip the part of the pitch where you brag.

Why property owners believe a third party over your pitch

Hiring a property manager means handing over a home and its rent on the strength of a phone call or two. The property owner can't see your repair times or your statements before they sign, so they look for proof from someone other than you.

  • Buyers trust outside voices more than yours. In a Gartner survey of 771 B2B buyers, published in 2023, buyers valued third-party interactions such as reading reviews and references 1.4 times more than a supplier's own digital channels.
  • Property owners judge you on fairness and follow-through. Across about 2,800 property owner survey responses on PropertyManagement.com (as of October 2026), property owners who felt maintenance costs were in line with the market gave their manager a Net Promoter Score of +71. Property owners who felt costs were significantly above market gave -62. Calls tell the same story: +70 from property owners whose calls get picked up, -1 from those who reach voicemail.
  • Google reviews of property managers come mostly from tenants. A star rating tells a property owner how renters feel about you. Survey results from your property owners show what someone in their shoes can expect.

Your profile puts that proof on one page, and every verified number on it shows when it was last updated.

What property owners see on your profile

Look at your profile the way a property owner will. In your PropertyManagement.com account, open Company Profile and click View Public Profile. The address looks like propertymanagement.com/property-manager/your-company-city-st, and it's the link you'll send at every step below.

A verified profile shows property owners:

  • Your company at a glance: your logo and description, doors managed, years in business and a Verified Identity mark from PropertyManagement.com.
  • Verified Performance: the operating numbers you publish, like Speed of Repair, Speedy Leasing, Occupancy Rate and Rent Collection Rate. Each one is measured from your own software, connected read-only, or from reports we check, and shows when the data was last updated.
  • Verified Credentials: credentials we check before they appear, such as NARPM Membership, Financial Trust, Tech Enabled and Asset Manager.
  • Property owner survey results: how your property owners rate you, from surveys PropertyManagement.com collects directly from your clients, with the number of responses behind them.
  • Customer Reviews & Ratings: your Google rating and review count.
  • Service area map: where you manage.
  • Contact Company: a button that lets a property owner message you from the page.

Membership adds tools on top of the free profile: website widgets, the email signature builder, and property owner introductions with no charge per introduction. It's $500 a month (cancel anytime) or $5,000 a year, and everything in the list above stays free either way.

Your Baseline Score stays private to your company. It lives in your dashboard and helps decide where you rank when property owners search by address, so keep it out of your sales materials and skip the dashboard screenshots.

Step 1: Your first reply

Your first reply is often where a property owner decides whether you're worth a call. Put your profile link in it, with one sentence on what they'll find. Do the same everywhere a property owner first hears from you: the reply to a web inquiry, the text after a missed call, the confirmation for a booked call and the intro email a referral partner forwards.

Edit the templates to match what your profile shows today. If you haven't set up Verified Performance yet, lead with your survey results.

Step 2: The management proposal

Proposals get forwarded to a spouse or a business partner who never heard your pitch. Give them a page that makes your case without you in the room.

Add a page called "Verified by PropertyManagement.com" right before your pricing:

  • Your profile link, plus a QR code on printed copies.
  • Screenshots of your Property owner survey results and Verified Performance sections, cropped so the "Data last updated" date shows.
  • Your Google rating beside your survey results, with one line on the difference: Google reviews of property managers come mostly from tenants, and the surveys go only to property owners.
  • A short paragraph on where the numbers come from. Paste this one and edit it to fit:

The same page works as a slide in your sales deck, one click before your ask.

Step 3: The sales call

When the property owner asks why they should pick you, stop pitching and share your screen. Open your live profile and let it answer.

If a property owner asks whether you pay to be on PropertyManagement.com, give a straight answer. Every company's profile and verification are free. Membership is paid and adds marketing tools and property owner introductions. Money never touches the math, so no fee buys a score, a ranking or a certification.

Show each property owner what they came for

  • A first-time landlord is afraid of surprise repair bills. Open your survey results on maintenance cost first.
  • A property owner leaving a manager who went quiet wants to know you'll answer. Show what your property owners say about your communication.
  • An investor comparing managers wants numbers. Walk through your Verified Performance, measured the same way for every company, so the comparison is fair.
  • An investor with rentals in several cities wants to know you cover them. Start with your service area map, then the numbers.

Step 4: The follow-up

After the call, the property owner compares you with the other managers they talked to. Make your follow-up the easiest proof in their inbox: the link, plus the part of your profile that answers the question they asked.

Send the link to your referral partners too. A real estate agent who refers a client to you is vouching for you, and your profile gives them proof to forward.

Step 5: Your email signature and website

Your email signature and your website put the profile in front of every property owner you deal with, without anyone on your team having to ask.

  • Email signature (free): add one line to every signature on your team, "Verified on PropertyManagement.com," linked to your profile. It takes two minutes in Gmail or Outlook.
  • Email signature builder (with Membership): on the Website Widgets page in your PropertyManagement.com account, the builder designs the whole signature with your logo and the badges you've earned. Upload a screenshot of your current signature or start from scratch, then copy it into Gmail or Outlook.
  • Website (free): link to your profile from your About page and next to your contact form, with a line like "Independently verified by PropertyManagement.com."
  • Website widgets (with Membership): widgets put your verified results on your own site. Email the install code to your web person from the same Website Widgets page.

Make your profile worth sending

A profile with little verified on it can't carry a sale. Each of these adds proof, and each one is free:

  • Turn on your property owner surveys. PropertyManagement.com sends them to your whole property owner list and follows up for you. See best practices for property owner surveys.
  • Set up Verified Performance. It's in beta and live for every verified company, free and paid. Connect your software or upload reports, and your repair times, leasing speed, occupancy and rent collection become proof a property owner can check. Open Verified Performance in your account, or start with how to connect your tools.
  • Add your credentials. Each one, from NARPM Membership to Asset Manager, is covered in how to get certified.
  • Go for the Top 100. Participation in our annual ranking is free. The rules are in How We Rank the 2027 Top 100.

Get Verified for Free

Claim your profile, then add the proof property owners look for: your property owner survey results and Verified Performance. All of it is free.

Get Verified for Free

Share this guide