Google’s Review Game Is Broken - And Here’s the Data That Proves It
We recently analyzed 8,747 property management companies across Google search results to understand what actually drives visibility on page 1. This wasn’t surface-level research. We pulled in star ratings, review volumes, BBB and Yelp presence, and then ran correlation analysis and probability testing. The results are clear, and frankly, they confirm what most PMs already feel: Google’s review game is broken.
Step 1: The Data
Total companies analyzed: 8,747 Labeled as on page 1 (from search results): 3,582 Labeled as pages 2-4: 5,165
From there, we tested how different reputation factors affect the odds of landing on page 1.
Step 2: Google Ratings = The Gatekeeper
We calculated the probability of being on page 1 given a company’s Google star rating. The cutoff was striking:
≥4.4 stars: 48.1% chance of being on page 1 <4.4 stars: 35.1% chance of being on page 1e 1
That’s a 13 percentage point gap - and it’s the cleanest single threshold we found. Google’s algorithm is making a blunt cut: drop below 4.4, and your visibility suffers.
Step 3: Review Volume = The Difference Maker
Next, we looked at review counts. Instead of raw numbers, we set a threshold at 300 reviews, since that’s where the math showed a major jump:
≥300 reviews: 63.5% chance of page 1 <300 reviews: 38.6% chance of page 1e 1
This is huge. It shows review volume has almost twice the weight of rating. Two companies could both have 4.5 stars - but the one with 500 reviews is dramatically more likely to rank on page 1.
Step 4: The "Other Platforms" Test (Yelp & BBB)
We also tested the impact of having a Yelp or BBB profile. Here’s what we found:
BBB & Yelp: 44.8% chance of page 1 Just BBB: 41.6% chance of page 1 Neither: 36.2% chance of page 1
Yes, having both gives you a small bump. But once we controlled for Google rating and review count in a logistic regression, the lift from Yelp/BBB essentially disappeared. In other words: Google doesn’t really care about these platforms. Owners might glance at them, but Google is rewarding what’s in its own sandbox.
💡 ChatGPT is a completely different story - Yelp matters here. Meanwhile BBB... barely matters.
Step 5: The Math Approach
For transparency:
We used Pearson correlation coefficients to measure how strongly each factor related to page 1 placement. Google rating (r = 0.16) and review volume (r = 0.15) both showed moderate positive correlation. Yelp and BBB presence were much weaker (r < 0.06). We also ran a logistic regression model. The results showed: Each +0.1 in Google rating -> ~4.8% higher odds of page 1 Doubling reviews at the median -> ~29% higher odds of page 1 Yelp and BBB presence added no meaningful lift once those were accounted for
This analysis isn't guesswork - it's statistical evidence that Google stars and reviews dominate.
Step 6: The Bigger Truth - Credibility Is the New Currency
Here’s the real problem: property managers are forced into a broken game. You’re chasing tenants for reviews, sweating every negative comment, and still hoping Google doesn’t bury you.
Owners don’t actually care about the mechanics of reviews. What they care about is credibility: can they trust you with their property? Right now, Google is the only public scoreboard. But it’s flawed. It reduces your entire operation to a single number and a star icon.
That’s why we built PropertyManagement.com. We’re creating the trust layer for the entire industry. Instead of leaving your credibility at the mercy of Google’s blunt instruments, you can:
Get verified and show objective proof of your performance Benchmark your company against peers with data-driven credibility metrics Control your reputation in one place - today, not "someday"
Final Word
If you want to survive Google’s game in the short term:
- Keep your rating at 4.4+
- Push steady review growth past 300 reviews
But if you want to thrive long term:
- Get verified on PropertyManagement.com and take control of your credibility before someone else defines it for you.
We’re here now, and we’ll be here long after the review treadmill breaks down. Our goal is simple: to elevate the entire property management industry.
Check out Unfiltered: PropertyManagement.com's Official Podcast
Get Verified on PropertyManagement.com
Announcements & Industry News
NARPM Annual Convention & Expo
Register here ->- we'll be there!
📆 When: October 20-23, 2025
⏰ Where: Orlando, FL
ProfitCoach Power Hour
Your monthly dose of practical insights for smarter PMs, stronger teams and bigger profits.
🎙️ Welcome to Unfiltered
Property management isn’t short on opinions - but most of them get smoothed out into conference-friendly soundbites. Unfiltered by PropertyManagement.com takes a different approach.
Hosted by Dylan Scroggins and Matt Speer, this is the podcast where we skip the fluff and talk about what’s actually happening inside PM companies. Expect sharp takes, honest debates, and the occasional contrarian view - the kinds of conversations you have in the hallway after a breakout session, not the ones from the stage.
Two Hosts, Two Angles
- Matt Speer, founder of PropertyManagement.com, brings scars and successes from scaling property management in Indianapolis and now building the industry’s trust layer. He’s not shy about calling out what’s broken - especially the review treadmill and the pay-to-play lead gen model.
- Dylan Scroggins, co-host and founder of Kalmar Group, adds a unique perspective from the recruiting side. His firm has placed leaders at companies like Evernest and RL Property Management, giving him a front-row seat to the talent and systems shaping the future of the industry. Dylan knows who’s winning, who’s hiring, and why it matters.
What You’ll Hear
- Operators at every level - from 1,000-door giants to 200-door independents - sharing the unvarnished realities of growth, retention, and credibility.
- Vendors and partners who see dozens of PMs up close each week, and can speak to the patterns others miss.
- Data-driven discussions around credibility, reviews, and the Top 100 rankings that PropertyManagement.com is rolling out.
Why Unfiltered
Because this industry doesn’t need another highlight reel. It needs a place where people can tell the truth, share lessons learned, and compare notes on what’s really working.
PropertyManagement.com is cementing itself as the trust layer in property management. Until that becomes the standard, managers are stuck playing the broken review game. Unfiltered is here to guide you through both worlds - helping you win in the short term while building credibility that lasts.
Closing Thoughts
Before you dive back into your day, here’s what’s worth remembering this week:
- Google isn’t subtle. The data shows a hard cutoff at 4.4 stars and a huge jump at 300+ reviews. If you’re under either line, your visibility drops fast.
- Chasing reviews is exhausting - and it’s a treadmill you’ll never fully win. But right now, you still have to play the game if you want page 1 visibility.
- BBB and Yelp? Marginal impact at best. Google cares about what’s in its own sandbox. Owners glance at those platforms, but they’re not the levers that move rankings.
- What owners actually care about is credibility. They want proof you’re the right partner, not just a star rating. That’s the trust gap PropertyManagement.com is filling.
The next wave of elite PMs won’t just collect reviews - they’ll control their credibility, benchmark themselves, and prove their performance in ways competitors can’t match.
So here’s the formula for right now:
Protect your Google rating. Drive steady review growth. Get verified on PropertyManagement.com and put your credibility on display.
Play the short game because you have to. Win the long game because you earned it.