Get verified for the Top 100 →
Rentals America logo

Rentals America

VerifiedElite · TrueMatch™ Verified
3000+Doors managed
18Years in business
95Property owners surveyed
4.5Google · 1038 reviews

At Rentals America, our mission is to deliver exceptional property management with simple, transparent, and affordable pricing. Property management is our sole focus, and our dedicated team works proactively to protect your investment, support your tenants, and make ownership stress-free. We value every client relationship and appreciate the opportunity to help you succeed as a rental property owner.

Verified Performance

Measured from the company’s own management software, connected read-only to PropertyManagement.com, or from reports it uploads and we check.

Rent Collection Rate

99.73%

Average Rent Collection Rate

Verified

Verified Credentials

Credentials are checked before they appear here: memberships against the association’s roster, training against the issuer, and accounting and pricing practices against independent data.

Financial TrustTech EnabledAsset Manager

Client survey results

Property owner survey results

Based on 95 property owner survey responses, collected by PropertyManagement.com directly from Rentals America’s clients.

Overall Satisfaction

95 property owner responses

Very dissatisfiedVery satisfied
9.8/10

Leasing Performance

9.5/10
Very dissatisfiedVery satisfied

Accounting & Financial Reporting

8.8/10
Very confusingVery easy to understand

Maintenance Communication

9.6/10
7+ daysUnder 24 hours

Maintenance Cost Value

7.0/10
7+ daysUnder 24 hours

Vacancy Time

8.0/10
61+ days0-14 days
Verified client survey aggregateData last updated May 19, 2026

Service area map

Area: smoothed merge of ~5 mi buffers (≈2 mi gap close). Dots: each ZIP centroid (darker = primary). Illustrative only. © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap

Customer Reviews & Ratings

Google
4.5

Based on 1000+ reviews

Better Business Bureau
A+

Based on 42 reviews

BBB and Yelp ratings are influenced by ads or paid accreditation. They are shown for transparency but don’t affect a TrueMatch™ score.

Frequently Asked Questions

What services does Rentals America provide for property owners?

Rentals America offers full-service residential property management, including marketing and leasing, tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance coordination, inspections, lease renewals, financial reporting, and compliance oversight. Our goal is to make rental ownership simple while protecting and growing your investment.

How do you market rental properties and reduce vacancy time?

We use wide-reaching advertising across major rental websites, professional listing optimization, and proactive leasing strategies to attract qualified tenants quickly. Our marketing approach is designed to minimize vacancy and secure strong applicants faster.

How do you screen tenants?

We conduct a thorough screening process that includes credit review, income and employment verification, rental history checks, and background screening. Our process is designed to place reliable tenants while reducing risk for property owners.

How do maintenance and repairs work?

We coordinate maintenance through a network of independent, licensed, and vetted vendors. Rentals America responds promptly to repair requests and does not add markups to maintenance or repair invoices. Owners benefit from professional coordination and oversight without the day-to-day stress of managing repairs themselves.

How do owners stay informed about their property?

Owners receive access to an online portal with real-time financial statements, maintenance updates, lease documents, and performance reporting. We prioritize clear communication and transparency so you always know how your property is performing.

What makes Rentals America different from other property management companies?

Property management is our sole focus. We combine experienced local teams, technology-driven systems, transparent pricing, and proactive management practices designed to protect property value and maximize long-term returns.

Can you manage properties for out-of-state or busy investors?

Yes. Many of our clients live out of state or prefer a hands-off investment approach. Our full-service model allows owners to enjoy the benefits of rental income without handling daily management responsibilities.