Penny Realty (TrueMatch Score: 93.27%) - Excellent Property Manager on PropertyManagement.com
TrueMatch Score93.27%
Book A Call
Quick summary
Penny Realty is a property management company based in San Diego, CA, with a TrueMatch™ score of 93.27 out of 100, They serve 64 surrounding markets, They manage 579+ units and and have been in business since (61 years).
500+
Doors Managed
60
Years Experience
468
Google Reviews

Company Overview

Penny Realty, Inc. has been proud to serve Southern California as a family-owned and operated property management company rooted in integrity, care, and long-standing relationships. Since our founding in 1965, we’ve believed that managing property isn’t just about homes and buildings — it’s about people. We understand that your rental property represents more than an investment; it reflects years of hard work, trust, and future planning. That’s why our owners choose Penny Realty — for the peace of mind that comes from working with a team that treats every property as if it were their own. At our core is the integrity of a family-owned business, the kindness of people who genuinely care, and the satisfaction that comes from serving the communities we live and work in. We believe in building relationships you can depend on, backed by the professionalism, knowledge, and experience of a dedicated team of property management experts. Property management, to us, is a partnership — a relationship between Penny Realty, our owner-clients, and our tenant-residents. When communication is clear, expectations are aligned, and trust is earned, everyone benefits. That philosophy has guided our work for generations and continues to define how we serve our clients today.

Customer Reviews & Ratings

Google
4.8
Based on 468 reviews
Better Business Bureau
A+

BBB and Yelp ratings are influenced by ads or paid accreditation. They are still shown for transparency but don’t affect TrueMatch score.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you screen prospective Tenants?

Penny Realty has a comprehensive 11 Step Screening Process. This process allows us to offer our “Eviction Free Guarantee.” For more details, see [PennyRealty.com/resident-screening](http://PennyRealty.com/resident-screening).

What insurance coverage should I have on my property?

Owners should maintain proper coverage. Consult your insurance agent for a Landlord/Rental Dwelling Insurance Policy. Penny Realty, Inc. should be named as an additional named insured. We also provide additional secondary coverage through SureVestor Insurance.

Who establishes the monthly rental rate for my property?

Penny Realty provides a comprehensive Rental Analysis and recommends competitive rates to maximize income and minimize vacancy. Final pricing is collaborative with the owner. If opting into Penny Realty’s Guarantees, Penny Realty will set the rental rate as required by the program.

What happens if the Tenant damages my property beyond the Security Deposit?

With the thorough 11 Step Tenant Screening Process, it is rare for damages to exceed the deposit. If it happens, Penny Realty will pursue collection in full and can support the owner through Small Claims Court. If needed, Legal Counsel’s Debt Collection division will pursue recovery after judgment.

How is the TrueMatch™ Score calculated?

We evaluate property management services across four key areas: performance efficiency, cost-effectiveness, reliability, and credibility. These scores reflect how well we manage vacancies and rent collection, deliver value for money, maintain consistent service and communication, and uphold industry standards through experience and proven success.
Penny Realty (TrueMatch Score: 93.27%) - Excellent Property Manager on PropertyManagement.com

Company Details

4444 Mission Blvd Suite 140, San Diego, CA 92109

Property Types

Affordable / Subsidized Housing Commercial Properties Condominiums Duplexes / Triplexes / Fourplexes Mixed-Use Multi-Family Single-Family Student Housing Townhouses Vacation Rentals / Short-Term Rentals

Credentials

Licensed Insured

Asset Class Focus

A-Class B-Class

Company Size

Sub-Enterprise [500-999]

Years in Business

60 years

Founded Year

1965

Verification Status

Verified by PropertyManagement.com

Contact Information

Ready to Get Started?

Connect with this verified property manager today.

Book A Call