Get verified for the Top 100 →
American West Realty and Management logo

American West Realty and Management

VerifiedElite · TrueMatch™ Verified
200+Doors managed
32Years in business
14Property owners surveyed
4.7Google · 243 reviews

Established in 1994, American West Realty and Management is the leading property management company in Cody and Powell, Wyoming. We offer a comprehensive solution for property owners, managing residential rentals, commercial space, and self-storage units. Our experienced sales team assists clients with buying or selling various properties, including residential, commercial, vacant land, and investments.

Trophy Case

1 award · 2025

PropertyManagement.com awards, earned on verified performance data and property owner surveys. They cannot be bought.

Top 100 and Market Leader are set by TrueMatch score on Nov 30 each year; Best in Class by property owner survey category, nationally and by metro. Ranks live on the Top 100 standings.

Verified Performance

Measured from the company’s own management software, connected read-only to PropertyManagement.com, or from reports it uploads and we check. Tap the (i) on any card to see how a number is measured.

Speed of Repair

7 days

Median days to complete repairs

Verified

via Software Sync · Nov 13

Occupancy Rate

91.1%

Occupancy rate

Verified

via Software Sync · Nov 13

Rent Collection Rate

99.79%

Rent collection rate

Verified

via Software Sync · Nov 13

Lease Renewal Rate

86.36%

Lease renewal rate

Verified

via Software Sync · Nov 13

All 4 verified metrics and the 1 credential published · Data last updated Nov 13, 2026

Verified Credentials

Credentials are checked before they appear here: licenses and insurance against the record, memberships against the association’s roster, technology against the tools in use.

LicensedInsuredTech Enabled

Client survey results

Property owner survey results

Based on 14 property owner survey responses, collected by PropertyManagement.com directly from American West’s clients.

Methodology: PropertyManagement.com invited property owners directly from American West Realty and Management's client roster. Responses are verified and screened for duplicate submissions.

Overall Satisfaction

14 property owner responses

Very dissatisfiedVery satisfied
9.6/10

Leasing Performance

Slow to leaseLeases fast
9.2/10

Maintenance Cost Value

Above marketIn line with market
8.2/10

Accounting & Financial Reporting

UnclearClear and on time
7.7/10

Maintenance Communication

Left in the darkKept informed
8.7/10

Vacancy Time

Long vacanciesFilled quickly
8.5/10
Verified client survey aggregate · all 6 categories publishedData last updated Aug 9, 2026

Team

The people property owners work with

Three people at American West Realty and Management. The company keeps it current from its dashboard.

DAY TO DAY WITH YOUR PROPERTY

Kristi Taylor

Kristi Taylor

Operations Manager


LEADERSHIP

Nathan Gesner

Nathan Gesner

Broker / Owner

Angie Gesner

Angie Gesner

COO / Owner

Service area

4 cities where American West Realty and Management manages homes today, confirmed from its synced portfolio.

Area: smoothed merge of ~5 mi buffers (≈2 mi gap close). Dots: each ZIP centroid (darker = primary). Illustrative only. © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap

Cody (primary)DeaverLovellPowell

Frequently asked questions

4 questions

Why should I hire you as my property management company?

We have personally used property managers in the past and understand how difficult it can be to find someone capable of caring for your investment. We encourage you to learn about property management, ask questions, review forms and contracts, check references, etc. After educating yourself, compare our offerings to the competition and make an informed decision. We also want to stress that we are not a perfect match for every owner and every property. The more you research other companies and us, the more comfortable you will feel when you decide to hire someone.

How do you qualify an applicant?

Our application process includes a full credit/criminal screening, identity verification, landlord references, and verification of employment or income. We look at how well applicants handle financial obligations, maintain previous rentals, and verify they can afford to rent your home. We screen every adult, 18 years of age or older.

Will you conduct regular inspections?

We conduct spot inspections any time we enter the home for maintenance, drive-by inspections, and a detailed annual inspection documented with pictures or video. Additional inspections may be triggered by late rent or other lease violations, or can be requested by the owner for a fee.

What happens if the tenant does not pay their rent?

Rent is due on the 1st and considered late after the 4th day of the month. A late fee is charged. If not paid in full by the 10th, we serve a 3-day Pay or Quit Notice. If not resolved, we file for eviction through the District Court. Thanks to our screening policy, we have not evicted one of our placed tenants since 2014. Each case is unique, and the property manager decides based on what is best for you and your home. Evictions generally happen within 30 days, minimizing impact on your income.