Just released: Property Management Industry Report. Explore vendor rankings and insights →
1st Choice Property Management — Verified property manager on PropertyManagement.com

1st Choice Property Management

Fort Worth, TX,Grand Prairie, TX,Aledo, TX,Argyle, TX
Quick summary
1st Choice Property Management is a property management company based in Fort Worth, TX, They serve 25 surrounding markets, They manage 534+ units and and have been in business since (34 years).
500+
Doors Managed
33
Years Experience
313
Google Reviews

Company Overview

1st Choice Property Management isn't a faceless company. We're a Fort Worth based business that has been managing homes across Tarrant County for decades. From the beginning, our guiding principle has been simple: care for properties, as if they were your own, and quality tenants will follow. Today, we carry that same belief forward – strengthened by modern technology, strong, vendor, partnerships, and a boots-on-the-ground commitment to serve our city.

Service area map

Certifications

Learn more

Rent Collection Rate

Average Rent Collection Rate98.61%

This company has verified its rent collection rate: the share of rent charged that was actually collected over the last 90 days. Higher verified collection rates earn higher certification tiers.

Verified
Learn more

Speedy Repair

Median Speed of Repair11.00 Days

This company has verified its speed of repair: the median time from a work order being created to the work being done, across all work orders completed in the last 90 days. Faster verified repair times earn higher certification tiers.

Verified
Learn more

Speedy Leasing

Median days on market14 days
Lead to Application Rate7.4%
Avg. lead response time8 secs
Verified
Powered by RentEngine
Learn more

Occupancy Rate

Occupancy Rate91.90 %

This company has verified the occupancy rate of its actively managed portfolio: occupied units as a share of all actively managed residential units, measured as a current snapshot. Higher verified occupancy earns higher certification tiers.

Verified
Learn more

Rental Price Accuracy

This company has verified that the rents it achieves track market rates, benchmarked against independent market data across its occupied portfolio. Tighter verified pricing earns higher certification tiers.

Verified
Learn more

Financial Trust

This company has verified that its trust accounts reconcile with its books, confirming proper trust accounting and security deposit handling.

Verified
Learn more

NARPM Membership

This company is an active member of the National Association of Residential Property Managers (NARPM), engaged in its professional standards and education programs.

Verified
Learn more

Tech Enabled

This company has verified that it runs on a vetted technology and vendor stack that delivers strong outcomes for property owners.

Verified

Customer Reviews & Ratings

Google
4.7
Based on 313 reviews
Yelp
3.8
Based on 11 reviews
Better Business Bureau
A+

BBB and Yelp ratings are influenced by ads or paid accreditation. They are still shown for transparency but don’t affect TrueMatch™ score.

Homeowner Survey Results

Data last updated on 02/28/2026, 9:13 AM CST

Overall Satisfaction
9.5 /10
Leasing Performance
9.4 /10
Accounting & Financial Reporting
7.8 /10

Company reviews

D**** L.
Angela is the best!!
K**** D.
I choose 1st Choice because their attention to the needs of the tenant matches my own. The property manager assigned to my tenants ensures their needs are meet in a timely fashion and they are well taken care of.
C**** P.
As a military member who had to rush off and leave my home being stationed overseas… I think first choice was my only choice! They came in completely took care of my home and I’ve been away for nearly 3 years and I’ve not had one issue! They handle everything and they are such an amazing team! If I have any questions, they are quick to communicate. I absolutely have no complaints about their service.!!

Frequently Asked Questions

What services do you provide?

Full-service rental management for single-family and small commercial properties: marketing, leasing, tenant screening, lease execution, rent collection, maintenance coordination, make-ready/project management, inspections, owner reporting, and compliance support.

Which areas do you serve?

Greater Fort Worth and nearby Tarrant County communities. Ask about out-of-area coverage for case-by-case projects.

How do I start property management with you?

Schedule a consultation, e-sign the management agreement, complete onboarding forms, provide keys/remotes/codes, and we'll conduct an initial condition walkthrough. During the consult, our BDM may discuss general needs; a separate make-ready inspection and detailed estimate are required to price specific work.

How is the TrueMatch™ Score calculated?

We evaluate property management services across four key areas: performance efficiency, cost-effectiveness, reliability, and credibility. These scores reflect how well we manage vacancies and rent collection, deliver value for money, maintain consistent service and communication, and uphold industry standards through experience and proven success.
1st Choice Property Management — Verified property manager on PropertyManagement.com

Company Details

5664 Denton Hwy, Fort Worth, TX 76148

Property Types

Commercial Properties Duplexes / Triplexes / Fourplexes Single-Family Townhouses

Credentials

Licensed Insured

Asset Class Focus

A-Class B-Class

Company Size

Sub-Enterprise [500-999]

Years in Business

33 years

Founded Year

1992

Verification Status

Verified by PropertyManagement.com

Contact Information

Ready to Get Started?

Connect with this verified property manager today.