Top Property Managers in Newburgh, NY
Property managers serving Newburgh — compare verified profiles and listed companies in this market
Colonial Property Management
VerifiedIntegrity Property Management
Verified360 Property Management
APM
Asset Property Services, Inc
Not sure which Newburgh manager fits your property?
Get your TrueMatch™Berry & Wythe Property Management
Carassone Property Management
Cornerstone Property Management
Fidelity Real Estate Management
McGrath Management LLC
Mid Valley Properties Management
Orange Flag Management
Renta Caza Property Management
River Realty Services, Inc.
River Realty Services, Inc.
Sam's Realty
Stevens Property Management Corp
Tinkelman Companies
Westage Companies
Find your perfect Newburgh property manager
- No credit card required
- Instant results
- No property manager can pay to change their score
Newburgh, NY market overview
Verified data from PropertyManagement.com's TrueMatch™ network — compare nearby cities or explore the coverage map.
Property management in Newburgh, NY
Newburgh, NY (New York) is served by 2 verified property management companies covering 4 ZIP codes.
Among ranked managers, the TrueMatch™ performance tier distribution is 2 Emerging — based on verified owner feedback, service quality, cost efficiency, and maintenance responsiveness.
Property owners in Newburgh use TrueMatch™ on PropertyManagement.com to compare managers by real performance data rather than paid reviews, ensuring they hire companies with documented coverage of their specific ZIP code.
Newburgh, NY rental market snapshot
Housing stock, renter share, home values, and gross rent context from the U.S. Census Bureau.
Households that rent
65.2% of households in Newburgh rent their home
6,839 renter-occupied of 10,493 occupied households
Housing stock
11,794 homes
Total residential housing units in Newburgh
Median home value vs median rent
Median home value $247,900 · Median rent paid $1,454 a month (includes utilities)
Monthly rent is about 0.59% of home value
Median gross rent reflects monthly rent paid by current renters including utilities; rent-to-value ratio is market context, not a property’s return.
Population
28,519 people live in Newburgh
View Newburgh Census ACS data table (2020–2024)
| Metric | Estimate | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Households that rent (B25003_003E / B25003_001E) | 65.2% | 6,839 of 10,493 occupied households |
| Homes (B25001_001E) | 11,794 | ±624 (90% MOE) |
| Median home value vs median rent (B25077_001E, B25064_001E) | $247,900 home value · $1,454/mo gross rent (0.59%) | Market context (not a property return) |
| Population (B01003_001E) | 28,519 | ±39 (90% MOE) |
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 5-year estimates, 2020–2024.
This product uses the Census Bureau Data API but is not endorsed or certified by the Census Bureau.
ZIP codes in Newburgh
Newburgh coverage area
Newburgh property management FAQs
How do I find the best property manager in Newburgh?
Use TrueMatch™ on PropertyManagement.com to match your Newburgh, NY property with 2 verified property management companies ranked on verified performance data—not paid reviews. Enter your address to see managers that serve your ZIP.
How much does property management cost in Newburgh?
Property management fees in Newburgh, New York typically run as a percentage of monthly rent plus leasing and other service fees. Exact rates vary by doors managed, services included, and neighborhood—compare verified managers in Newburgh with TrueMatch™ for quotes tied to your property.
Is a property manager worth it in Newburgh?
For most Newburgh owners who live out of area or manage multiple doors, a verified manager is worth it when they protect occupancy, handle maintenance, and stay compliant with New York landlord-tenant rules. TrueMatch™ surfaces managers with owner-verified performance so you can weigh cost against outcomes.
How many property management companies serve Newburgh?
Newburgh, New York is served by 2 verified property management companies across 4 ZIP codes. Among ranked managers, the TrueMatch™ tier mix is 2 Emerging.
What should I look for in a Newburgh property manager?
Prioritize verified local coverage for your ZIP, transparent fee structures, responsive maintenance, and documented owner references. TrueMatch™ ranks Newburgh managers using verified performance signals instead of paid placement.
Looking for property managers in a different location?
Enter your property address to get started with personalized property manager recommendations.